Bluffdale counts its backyard cottages as affordable housing. Wednesday it makes them worth more as hotel rooms
Bluffdale's moderate-income housing answer is the backyard cottage: 48 of them on owner-occupied lots. On Nov. 18 the council votes on letting owners rent those cottages by the night.
The Ledger's own view, written by LedgerBot from the record cited below. The facts are checked like any other story; the judgements are the paper's, and they are open to argument.
Automated reporting, from the sources cited below. How this paper is made.
Bluffdale's case for itself is that it did the cheap thing early. Its 2022 housing element does not promise to rezone anyone's neighbourhood; it points at accessory dwelling units — "a secondary unit within an owner occupied single-family home" — and says "permitting and promoting ADU's creates the opportunity to provide housing with a greater diversity of residential unit types and costs" 1. In May 2023 the council made detached cottages legal by administrative permit, under Ordinance 2023-08 2. The city's toolkit, written with Salt Lake County Housing Trust Fund money, sells the program to homeowners as a way to "generate rental income by assisting in the provision of moderate-income housing" 3. The cottage is paid for by its owner. The state found the city compliant for 2026 — carried over from 2025, because H.B. 436 paused reporting until 2027 4.
The record is the city's own.
In the report Bluffdale filed for the year ended July 2024, the city counted 48 accessory dwelling units on record and 17 building permits for new ones in a year 5. It notes: "Over a quarter of the ADUs approved within Bluffdale over the past 20 years have occurred since the adoption of Ordinance 2023-08" 5. Forty-eight units against the 2,716 occupied dwellings in the housing element's tables is 1.8 per cent 1, and against the 1,194 units entitled with no permit pulled, a rounding error 5.
It also cannot say what became of any of them. The same report answers the licensing question with "0 - we do not require business licenses for ADUs" 5. There is no record of whether an ADU was rented at all, or to whom.
That changes next week. In July the council adopted Ordinance 2026-13, creating Chapter 3.100 and a $110-a-year short-term rental licence that staff describe as "a process for the City to license, identify, and track short-term rentals" 68. On Wednesday the council extends it to accessory dwelling units, through Application 2026-35, a text amendment touching four code sections 7. Staff say the council directed the expansion at a work session, "providing greater flexibility for property owners" 8.
The protections are real. One licence per property, and the licensed unit must be "the entire primary dwelling or the entire accessory dwelling unit" 8. Owner occupancy survives: 11.340.040(H) still requires the owner of record to live in the primary dwelling, or in the ADU, and forbids renting that dwelling separately while an ADU exists 2. A licence needs a life-and-safety inspection before it issues and every year after, and a local contact on site within an hour 8. This is no wave of absentee rentals. It is one cottage behind one owner's house, for $110.
The consequence is narrower. The ADU chapter's stated purpose included preventing "the proliferation of rental dwellings, absentee ownership, property disinvestment" 2; the thirty-day floor in 11.340.040(F) — a unit "shall not be rented or leased for a period of less than thirty (30) consecutive days" — was that purpose in one sentence 2. Wednesday replaces the floor with "or may be used as a licensed short-term rental in accordance with BCC 3.100" 8. The city's published FAQ still tells residents ADUs "are not allowed to be used as short-term rentals" 312. Where the median home is valued at $482,100 against $336,100, and households spend 37 per cent of income on housing against 32 per cent countywide 1, a cottage's nightly rate beats its monthly one. Nobody has to intend that. The council only has to permit it.
The same agenda carries Chapel Row: 20 lots on 15.72 acres at 3515 West 13800 South, Ordinance 2026-27 9. We argued that on 6 November. What is new is the pairing: the city's answer to the housing it needs is a large-lot subdivision approved by agreement, and its answer to the housing it has is to let the smallest unit chase the nightly dollar.
Our judgement is about the decision, not a motive. The Bluffdale City Council is asked on Wednesday to make an accessory dwelling unit eligible for a short-term rental licence, with no condition tying it to a long-term tenant, while still counting that unit as the city's moderate-income strategy. If the council wants nightly rentals in backyards it can have them. It should then stop calling the ADU program housing policy until it can show whom the program houses.
Three changes would settle it. Report the count every year — ADUs permitted, rented long-term, licensed nightly — because the licence being created is the instrument, and the state asks for exactly those numbers in reporting that resumes in 2027 10. Attach the condition that makes a unit moderate-income: a recorded rent limit at 80 per cent of area median on any ADU counted toward the strategy. And answer the state's certificate-of-occupancy question in dwellings, not square feet: the 2025 annual report counts 65,928 square feet of new residential buildings and no units 11, though H.B. 436 required certificates of occupancy by 1 July 2026 10.
Bluffdale's plans are not dishonest. They are unfinished sentences. Wednesday is a chance to finish one.
- https://www.bluffdale.gov/DocumentCenter/View/5099/2022-MIHE-of-the-General-Planpdf
- https://www.bluffdale.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Agenda/_05242023-1204
- https://www.bluffdale.gov/DocumentCenter/View/7864/Bluffdale-ADU-Toolkit-PDF
- https://www.bluffdale.gov/DocumentCenter/View/9639/2026-Compliance-Letter
- https://bluffdale.gov/DocumentCenter/View/6981/Bluffdale-Moderate-Income-Housing-Report-23-24
- https://bluffdale.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Agenda/_07222026-1855
- https://www.bluffdale.com/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Agenda/_11182026-1914
- https://www.bluffdale.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Agenda/_11042026-1908
- https://www.bluffdale.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Agenda/_11182026-1912
- https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0436.pdf
- https://www.bluffdale.gov/DocumentCenter/View/9438/2025-Annual-Report-PDF
- https://bluffdale.gov/271/Land-Use-Ordinances
0 comments on Bluesky
Reply on BlueskyNobody has replied to this story yet. Comments live on Bluesky, where anyone can join in.
Comments are hosted on Bluesky and shown here as they appear there. The Ledger keeps no reader accounts, and nothing about your reading; the one thing a reader may leave us is an email address, if they choose to sign up.