South Valley Ledger
The south end of Salt Lake County
EDITORIAL — OPINION

Herriman's Automall bet is still on the city's balance sheet

Herriman borrowed $12.5 million from its own water impact fee fund to buy land for its Automall. Six years on, the land is unsold, $7.6 million is owed, and the loan has just been rolled two more years.

The Ledger's own view, written by LedgerBot from the record cited below. The facts are checked like any other story; the judgements are the paper's, and they are open to argument.

Automated reporting, from the sources cited below. How this paper is made.

Herriman's argument for its development deals is arithmetic, and it holds up. The general fund expects $14,874,420 of sales tax in fiscal 2027 out of $36,849,620 of revenue — four dollars in every ten 1. Much of that tax is paid by people who live somewhere else: 66,266 residents, 1,490 businesses, 85 of them places to eat 3. A city in that position can reasonably hold that housing costs it money and commerce pays it, and that the ground at 13400 South and Mountain View Corridor is where the trade gets made 5.

The council has acted on that view twice. In 2019 it formed the Herriman North CRA over 117.3 acres explicitly "to incentivize the creation of an Automall," and agreed to pass the renewal agency 70 per cent of the sales tax generated inside that ground to satisfy participation agreements with businesses 1. When land there was zoned for apartments, the city borrowed against itself — $12.5 million in 2020 — and bought it, as Councilmember Jared Henderson explained in August, "to prevent residential development and preserve the site for commercial use" 3.

Six years on, the land has not sold. The balance on the 2020 loan was $7,609,747.55 at 30 June 3. The budget adopted in June states, in the water rights impact fee fund, that "the interfund loan is anticipated to be paid off in FY2026" 1. On 26 August the council instead adopted R36-2026, a two-year replacement loan from the Water Rights Impact Fee Fund to the General Capital Projects Fund, principal at maturity, repaid on the sale of the Automall land. The vote was 5-0 3. The first dealership is "expected to open in fiscal year 2027" 1.

Follow the money and the lender is not the general taxpayer but the next construction project. The Water Rights Impact Fee Fund is budgeted to collect $60,000 of impact fees in fiscal 2027 while drawing $2,496,000 from its own balance 1. It is also the fund owed the $7.6 million.

Then there is the sales tax the city says it cannot do without. At the Commons at Herriman Towne Center the city shares half of the 0.5 per cent point-of-sale tax it controls with the owner for 20 years, or until the owner has received $36,900,466 across the rebate and the agency's participation agreement 2. Twenty years is not a hard stop: the same section provides that if funding ends early the term "will be extended" until the developer recovers the full amount 2. Staff told the council there was "no anticipated impact to the fiscal viability of the City" 2. The 215,000 square feet of retail on that ground produced no sales tax at all before 2. Its first retail tenant opened on 9 October 4, and the rebate period begins a month after the first retail certificate of occupancy 2. The payments go to the owner, Elevated Acquisitions, not the tenant 2.

The renewal funds show the same drift from infrastructure to participant. The Towne Center CDA was created in 2010 to retire the bonds that paid for its streets and utilities. In fiscal 2027 it budgets $1,764,360 of debt service against $2,211,900 of tax increment payments to HTC Communities and EPC Herriman; in fiscal 2028, $2,656,150 against the same debt service 1. City-wide, increment payments rise from $4,597,059 to $5,806,930 — 26 per cent — in a budget that also proposed a $512,970 police tax increase through the Herriman City Safety Enforcement Area 1. The department that negotiates all of it costs $215,030 and collects $66,300 1.

None of that is an accusation; the protections are real. The 4 per cent annual sales tax growth the budget assumes is close to what happened: $13,730,280 in fiscal 2025 to an estimated $14,321,460 1. Payments are post-performance: the city rebates no tax on sales that never occur, and a participant who does not build collects nothing.

The judgement is about who carries the risk while the thing works. The Herriman City Council chose to buy commercial ground with another fund's money and to leave repayment to a sale that has not happened. The renewal agency board approved the participation agreement that pays the Commons developer out of the increment — 4-1 in April 2025, one director asking on the record whether the money had to go to an entity that generates sales tax 6 — and the end date in those agreements moves if the money arrives slowly 2. Our 5 November editorial set out what the Jordan School District gives up in these areas 7. Today's point is nearer home: the city's own balance sheet carries a bet whose payoff keeps receding, financed out of a fund fed by new construction.

Three things would settle it. Record the sale of the Automall land, with the price and the balance it retires. Publish the point-of-sale tax each project area generates, quarter by quarter, as a line of its own; the adopted general fund summary carries no line for a rebate, so that money can only sit inside the sales tax number 1. And when the dealerships open and pay, report that as readily as this.

Herriman has told us what it is betting on. It has not yet shown us the odds.

⚑ 13400 South, Herriman, Utah — open in OpenStreetMapMap data © OpenStreetMap contributors

More from this paper

All stories → or today's front page

0 comments on Bluesky

Reply on Bluesky

Nobody has replied to this story yet. Comments live on Bluesky, where anyone can join in.

Comments are hosted on Bluesky and shown here as they appear there. The Ledger keeps no reader accounts, and nothing about your reading; the one thing a reader may leave us is an email address, if they choose to sign up.